Star wars vs lord of the rings book

Star wars vs lord of the rings themed death battles. In lord of the rings book three, return of the king. George lucas was the guy who came up with star wars, but left to his own devices, he also came up with episodes i, ii and iii. Star wars vs harry potter vs lord of the rings vs game of. Lord of the rings and star warsstar wars effects added to lord of the rings a few errors, but im not gonna bother to fix them. Lord of the rings i am basing this on the lord of the rings films as i have not read the books. The prequels might be mentioned, but their stories and characters wont be considered here. Lord of the rings vs star wars first of all, lordoftherings, starwars, babylonfive are all the artussaga, they have merlin, holygrail and and and. Leave dakota alone, eregon was a great book if massively influence by star wars and lord of the rings. The consistency throughout the movies in quality is far better in lotr as well.

I hear what youre complaining about, but i think that you are being to harsh on chris and any fans. For example, shakespeares macbeth revolves largely around macbeths reaction to the prophecy of the witches. Both have original trilogys, both have over the top. Everyone has seen star wars and lord of the rings but nobody wants to answer the. I enjoy both but starwars doesnt have a book to suffer in comparison. Well, they all have different things going for them. That novel, first published in 1884, is many things, including a satire of victorian social customs. This is perhaps the most affordable star wars movie for those who dont know. Its no coincidence that so many major sources for star wars were influenced by shakespeare.

Lord of the rings versus the hobbit any time that there is more than one story set in the same universe, then you are just begging for comparison. Star wars didnt have the best movies aside from a new hope. I, and millions of other people have loved tolkiens lord of the rings books and the movies that came out of them. The original star wars trilogy vs the lord of the rings trilogy. George lucas has said that he was influenced by tolkiens work, which is considered one of the most meaningful and significant works in the 20th century. Thats a new hope, the empire strikes back and return of the jedi for star wars and the fellowship of the ring, the two towers and the return of the king for lord of the rings. Indiana jones, and today we move on to two of the biggest epics in film history. Potter a myth or story on the same level as lord of the rings andor star wars.

Star wars has more public appeal, but lotr has had a greater impact on modern fantasy at least book wise. Lordoftheringspartone is a splendidly antihypnocratic experience serving to underline the poverty of imagination of such pablum sagas as the starwars flicks. Id take halo and star wars over lord of the rings and game of thrones any day. The films of middleearth the lord of the rings trilogy and the hobbit trilogy share a good number of actors with the many films and television series of the marvel cinematic universe lets. Film lord of the rings vs star wars originals thread starter aaronreddevil. The original star wars trilogy vs the lord of the rings. Before peter jacksons films would inspire the more recent installments of star wars, george lucas certainly took inspiration from tolkiens work in the hobbit and the lord of the rings. Come in to read stories and fanfics that span multiple fandoms in the lord of the rings and star wars rebels universe.

Star wars and the lord of the rings both feature racist stereotypes i am not talking about jar jar binks and the neimoidians, neither of whose alleged ethnic influences have ever been successfully pinned down by irate fans. Lord of the rings star wars wavelength stuart carapola on. I also used two lists of star wars and lord of the ringshobbit films respectively, although the. Lotr and the hobbit are both beloved books and beloved movie series. Saruman sauron with the ring sauron without the ring darth vader. Lord of the rings is an amazing book series and the story behind the writings that eventually created the hobbit is beautiful in itself, but as far as a cinematic phenomenon and all round better film series in my opinion, star wars takes the cake. Randal jeff anderson argues with elias trevor fehrman and a hobbit lover kevin weisman over the merits of star wars versus the lord of the rings film description. I will share a valuable parallel between this epic story and what is happening in this election that i hope touches you. In early drafts of the star wars screenplay, luke even has a line of dialogue lifted directly from the books, thought it never made it to the final film. Sure, star wars has tons of books, but disney just retconned them out of the eu. Buy bsw mens harry pott lord of the rings star wars jedi green saber shirt. Star wars and lord of the rings crossover fanfiction archive with over 57 stories. Certainly theres just as many pages in the written starwars canon as in tolkien. Id say lotr, for it has amazing books and movies, plus the silmarillion is a lore nerds dream.

Mapping new congruencies between the internet and media entertainment culture elana shefrin the culture of media entertainment, as exempli. Death battles, movies themed death battles, rivalry themed death battles, movie vs. The lord of the rings lord of the rings books vs movies. Both draw upon the same themes modeled after the classic greek tragic hero.

Yesterday, we presented the first matchup, back to the future vs. We duke it out with the two largest movie franchises of all time. By the midsixties the lord of the rings was probably the most influential fantasy story in the western world, occupying the same position star wars did in the late seventies and wagners ring cycle did toward the end of the 19th century. Lord of the rings as a movie and as a book trilogy. So when you compare apples to apples first run box office vs first run box office, potter beats star wars. But while star trek featured oodles and oodles of worldbuilding.

Shop top fashion brands tshirts at free delivery and returns possible on eligible purchases. Lord of the rings star wars, and participatory fandom. Most people would pit star wars against star trek, but whilst i think that is a great debate, there is no doubt the next one people like to argue about are the lord of the rings and star wars. Come in to read stories and fanfics that span multiple fandoms in the star wars and lord of the rings universe. Test your knowledge on this movies quiz to see how you do and compare your score to others. I loved the first lotr and ttt was good too but rotk was like watching the end half of ttt twice but with little differences on how the huge battles took place. It makes it all the easier that tolkien purposefully wrote both stories with decidedly different tones as well as intent. Lord of the rings and star wars rebels crossover fanfiction. Bsw mens harry pott lord of the rings star wars jedi.

Fantasy is just so much better than sci fi to me so for that reason this is a nonstarter. Star wars peter jacksons glorified video trivia game doesnt hold up to the grandly human epic that defined a generation. Were also going to need to break down these movies part by part. Between a variety of projects in movies and on tv, the nerd world has an embarrassment of riches with all the various scifi and fantasy properties coming to life. The fellowship of the ring movie the phantom menace movie who is the best villain. Evil ya know, they need to destroy the ring and stuff. The fellowship of the ring each is the fourth entry chronologically, though the first in production, of an iconic film saga. History talk 0 these are whatif death battles where a star wars character fights a lord of the rings character.

Complicating matters for the star wars vs lord of the rings debate is that. Star wars notched a 20point victory over doctor who, but that paled in comparison to the oldfashion stomping that lord of the rings gave harry potter in a 7426 rout. They are curious, innovative blends of many cultural influences and george lucas should be commended for stirring so much. Lord of the rings movies vs star wars yahoo answers. Star wars lord of the rings which did you like the best. Both star wars and the lord of the rings have book and movie versions. Julian mays sage of pliocene exile, the ultimate scifantasy series.

Additionally star wars the clone wars and rebels animated series producer dave filoni, inspired the development of ahsoka tano on gandalf from the lord of the rings novels and films. Lord of the rings, star wars, and participatory fandom. From star wars to lord of the rings, how to build a world literary. Based on the fact that you put all of the star wars characters first, im guessing you prefer star wars to lord of the rings. Both involve individuals of all age groups and genders. Dune, the lord of the rings, forbidden planet and kurusawa kurosawas ran, 1985, was a remake of king lear. Just becaused paolini plagerised a ton of books doesnt mean that it took away for the greatness of the book. Original star wars trilogy vs the lord of the rings. Most people would pit star wars against star trek, but whilst i think that is a. Lord of the rings is now more popular than star wars why. At the end sam and frodo find amon amarthband playing on amon. It would be unfair to put them side by side as a book vs. Star wars deals will mystical elements within the milieu of advanced scientific technology, while the lord of the rings deals with mystical elements within the aura of magic.

Can you name the similarities between star wars and the hobbitthe lord of the rings. Lord of the rings was based off of some of the best books ever written or that will ever be written. Granted, potter has a lot of built in advantages over star wars, including but not limited to having a built in fan basemany of whom are entire familiesfrom the novels and this little thing called the internet. This doesnt seem to be a question so ill just give you my opinion.

Star wars is cool, but doesnt make sense if you think about it too much. And they stayed as close to the books as they thought possible so naturally it came out wonderful. Next, star wars and the lord of the rings are different genres. New posts more than 50 replies or 500 views closed thread. From star wars to lord of the rings, how to build a world. Lord of the rings and star wars rebels crossover fanfiction archive with over 2 stories.

Original star wars trilogy vs the lord of the rings trilogy. What happens when you take a legendary team of heroes and villains, give them lightsabers and force powers. Lotr is set way, waaayyyy back then, and star wars is, like, 70 years into the future. The scifi behemoth star wars goes headtohead against the fantasy giant the lord of the ringsthe hobbit franchise.

Star wars and lord of the rings crossover fanfiction. If you want to compare a book with a movie then youre question would make more sense. I love all three of star wars films and i cant say the same for lotr. Do you prefer the lord of the rings, or the star wars saga so all six films.